Understanding Religion in Vast Early America


Hello Reader,

Today we’re interviewing a historian who investigated an Afro-Caribbean religion called Obeah, and whose work asks us to consider religious freedom in light of a religion that was, and in some places still is, outlawed.

In 1760 Jamaica legislators banned “Obeah Men and Women” from using “Blood, Feathers, Parrots Beaks, Dogs Teeth, Alligators Teeth, broken Bottles, Grave Dirt, Rum, Egg-shells, or any other Materials relative to the Practice of Obeah or Witchcraft” (Section X). White colonists viewed Obeah from the outside and left behind documents like this law recording their views, which related Obeah to witchcraft. But understanding what Obeah looked like from the perspective of Afro-Caribbean practitioners, who were often enslaved, is a much harder historical question to answer.

Today, Katharine Gerbner joins us to show how archival discoveries and close readings reveal a new history of Obeah. Katharine is an Associate Professor of History and Director of the Religious Studies Program at the University of Minnesota. You might remember her from Episode 206 of Ben Franklin’s World, where she discussed her first book, Christian Slavery: Conversion and Race in the Protestant Atlantic World. Today, she’s sharing details from her most recent book, Archival Irruptions: Constructing Religion and Criminalizing Obeah in Eighteenth-Century Jamaica. Here’s Katharine to share more about the history of Obeah and religion in vast early America.

Tell us about your book in two or three sentences. What's the big story you're uncovering?

My book shows how Obeah, an Afro-Caribbean religion, became a crime in Jamaica. Obeah was outlawed in 1760 after Tacky’s Revolt, the largest slave rebellion in the eighteenth-century British empire, and it is still illegal today. My book examines what Obeah meant before it was criminalized and shows how slavery shaped what is deemed a legitimate “religion.” I argue that we cannot understand religion – or the ideal of religious freedom – without examining slave rebellion and the criminalization of Africana religious practices.

What first sparked your interest in this topic?

When I was doing research for my first book, Christian Slavery, I found a rare description of Obeah from the 1750s that no other historian had discovered. The documents I uncovered were written in an archaic form of German called Kurrent and recorded by Moravian missionaries who arrived in the Caribbean in 1754. Reading through these archives, it became clear to me that Afro-Caribbeans considered Moravian Christianity to be comparable to Obeah. Since most historical evidence about Obeah was produced after it was criminalized, I knew these documents offered an opportunity to tell a new story about Obeah, and I wanted to tell that story.

What's one surprising or little-known detail you discovered in your research?

By reading the Moravian records closely, I found that many Afro-Caribbean people saw the missionaries’ Christianity as a form of Obeah, and they referred to the first Moravian missionary as an Obeah man. I read these sources for what I call “irruptions,” moments when Afro-Caribbean perspectives break through the missionaries’ own accounts. What emerges is a picture of Obeah as a practice centered on healing, prophecy, and community protection. This is very different from the perception of Obeah today. Currently, there is a debate in Jamaica about whether Obeah should be decriminalized. These early sources indicate what the practice of Obeah meant before Tacky’s Revolt.

Why does this story matter for understanding the early American past or the present?

My research offers new insight into the meaning of religious freedom. In a very literal sense, the modern definition of religion was constructed as the inverse of “criminal” and “superstitious” practices such as Obeah. The traditions that were excluded from the category of religion have been marginalized ever since, both in historical scholarship and in everyday life. We need to change our definition of religion to better realize the ideal of religious freedom.

If you could invite readers into one scene from your book, what moment would you choose and why?

Chapter 3 opens with a meeting between Accompong, a leader of the Jamaican Marooons, and the Moravian missionary George Caries. The Maroons were communities of African and Indigenous descent who escaped slavery and established their own governments in Jamaica’s mountainous interior. I invite readers to see that meeting from Accompong’s point of view rather than the missionaries. The chapter also introduces Margery, a Maroon woman who has never been identified before. By tracing her movements through the missionary records, I show how important she was to her Maroon community, to the practice of Obeah, and to the growth of the Afro-Moravian congregation. In this way, while my research focuses on Obeah, it also reveals new information about the Jamaica Maroons.

What's one historical source, artifact, or place you'd recommend for readers who want to explore this topic further?

The historian Diana Paton’s website, obeahhistories.org, is a wonderful place to explore more sources about the history of Obeah, as is her site on religious freedom and Caribbean religion, Freedom to Believe. Jamaica is also currently debating whether Obeah should remain a crime, and the Jamaica Gleaner and the Jamaica Observer have been following the story.

For readers interested in new sources, I am currently researching a document that reveals a different story about religious persecution and slavery. In 1739, Damma, a formerly enslaved African woman on St. Thomas (now part of the U.S. Virgin Islands), wrote to the Queen of Denmark advocating for freedom of worship for Black women in the Moravian congregation. Remarkably, she wrote it in both Dutch Creole and her native West African language, Gbe. With a team of West African and Creole linguists and historians, we are translating the Gbe text for the first time, and our initial findings are available in a digital project called Adga Tome.

Where can readers learn more about your work?

I have a website katharinegerbner.com that includes links to all of my articles, books, podcasts interviews, and documentary appearances. You can also find me on LinkedIn and Bluesky, @ktgerbs.



🎧 Go Deeper

Explore some mystical and witchy parts of early America history with these episodes of Ben Franklin's World.

🎧 Episode 341: Mairi Cowan, Possession and Exorcism in New France​ ​

🎧 Episode 053: Emerson W. Baker, A Storm of Witchcraft​

🎧 Episode 370: Malcolm Gaskill, The Ruin of All Witches​

🎧 Episode 192: Brian Regal, The Secret History of the New Jersey Devil​


💬 Join the Conversation

Katharine uses multiple languages to understand religion in the Caribbean, how would knowing another language (or working with someone who does) change your research into the past?

📝 Hit Reply to share your thoughts. 💬 Join the conversation in our Listener Community.
​

Thank you for reading and considering.

Have a great week,

Liz Covart

Host, Ben Franklin's World​


🧭 Discover your history style: Take the free quiz​

❤️ Support our work: Make a donation​

📨 Enjoy this? Forward it to a friend!

📚 New here? Subscribe​

📓 Affiliate Disclosure

Links to books in this email are affiliate links through Bookshop.org. Each purchase supports local, independent bookstores and helps sustain Ben Franklin's World at no additional cost to you.

Ben Franklin's World

​Unsubscribe | Update your profile | P.O. Box 180002, Boston , MA 02118

Ben Franklin's World: Early American History

Curious about how early America actually worked, and how it still shapes the world you live in? Each week on the Ben Franklin's World podcast, historian Liz Covart, Ph.D., sits down with the scholars who study early American history to explore the people, places, and events between 1450 and 1825. Not myths. The evidence, in plain, language. Winner of the Academy of Podcasters' 2017 Best History Podcast Award and the Daughter of the American Revolution's inaugural Franklin New Media Award, Ben Franklin's World has been downloaded more than 14 million times, and reaches lifelong learners, teachers, family historians, and heritage travelers in more than 100 countries. The newsletter goes further: It investigates what doesn't fit in our episodes, what to read next, and how the past connects to the present. Two to three emails a week. No hot takes, no jargon — just history, told well.

Read more from Ben Franklin's World: Early American History

Hello Reader, On November 16, 1776, the Continental Navy Brig Andrew Doria sailed into the harbor of Sint Eustatius, a small Dutch island in the Caribbean, and fired a cannon salute. Overlooking Statia’s harbor, atop a large cliff sat Fort Oranje, the Dutch fort where Sint Eustatius Governor Johannes de Graaff ordered his soldiers to return the Americans’ salute. Statia’s returned salute, known as The First Salute, stands as the first international recognition of the United States as an...

Hello Reader, When we think about the foreign help that won American independence, most of us think of France. But in April 1781, John Adams wrote to a very different set of leaders: the States General of the Dutch Republic. He told them the Dutch and the Americans were so alike that the history of one seemed “but a transcript” of the other. Adams needed Dutch recognition and Dutch loans. But he wasn’t the first American to find help in the Dutch Republic. Dutch merchants had been selling...

Hello Reader, What do you see when you look at this early nineteenth-century long rifle? A weapon, a tool, a work of craftsmanship? You might be wondering if it was used as a means of feeding or protecting a family, a display of wealth, or an object of violence? Henry Bruner III, Long Rifle, 1810-1815, curly maple, brass, and silver, Rowan County North Carolina, USA, Acc. No. 560, Museum of Early Southern Decorative Arts. Check out this object and explore MESDA's collections here Your initial...