Curious about how early America actually worked, and how it still shapes the
world you live in?
Each week on the Ben Franklin's World podcast, historian Liz Covart, Ph.D., sits down with
the scholars who study early American history to explore the people, places, and
events between 1450 and 1825. Not myths. The evidence, in plain, language.
Winner of the Academy of Podcasters' 2017 Best History Podcast Award and the Daughter of the American Revolution's inaugural Franklin New Media Award, Ben Franklin's World has been downloaded more than 14 million times, and reaches lifelong learners, teachers, family historians, and heritage travelers in more than 100 countries.
The newsletter goes further: It investigates what doesn't fit in our episodes, what to read next, and how the past connects to the present.
Two to three emails a week. No hot takes, no jargon — just history, told well.
Share
Firearms and Daily Life in Early America
Published 11 days ago • 5 min read
Hello Reader,
What do you see when you look at this early nineteenth-century long rifle? A weapon, a tool, a work of craftsmanship? You might be wondering if it was used as a means of feeding or protecting a family, a display of wealth, or an object of violence?
Henry Bruner III, Long Rifle, 1810-1815, curly maple, brass, and silver, Rowan County North Carolina, USA, Acc. No. 560, Museum of Early Southern Decorative Arts. Check out this object and explore MESDA's collections here
Your initial perceptions might be shaped by your personal experiences, your political views, and local, national, and international events that have unfolded since this object was made in the early nineteenth century. But how did early Americans see firearms and how were they used used day to day?
Today we’re joined by a historian who took a close look at firearms in North Carolina, showing how laws and daily use shaped the place of these objects in early American society. Antwain Hunter is an Assistant Professor of History at The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Today, he’s sharing details from his first book, A Precarious Balance: Firearms, Race, and Community in North Carolina, 1715-1865. Here’s Antwain to tell us more about everyday gun use in early America.
Tell us about your book in two or three sentences. What's the big story you're uncovering?
At the core of A Precarious Balance, I am trying to understand how Black North Carolinians accessed and used firearms and how different people—free and enslaved Black folks, state and local leaders, enslavers, and nonslaveholding white people—tried to navigate this issue. I am also interested in the wide range of pragmatic things, both legal and illegal, that enslaved people did with firearms to improve their lives.
What first sparked your interest in this topic?
I have to credit Bill Blair, one of my professors, for an assist in the discovery process. In his Civil War seminar at Penn State back around 2010 or so he had us examine digital collections of primary sources and I chose Loren Schweninger’s Race and Slavery Petitions Project. I was reading through the petitions and came across a few from 1830s Delaware in which white folks petitioned the state legislature to prevent free and enslaved Black people from having firearms. I was struck by this. I had been in a few different graduate courses where we talked about firearms and masculinity but I, as a graduate student deeply interested in the history of enslavement, had never thought about the racial dynamics of firearms until Bill’s assignment.
What's one surprising or little-known detail you discovered in your research?
One of the things that caught me off guard during my research, and which also surprises many of the people I talk to, is just how many Black North Carolinians had access to firearms in the colonial and antebellum eras. Prior to this research, I assumed that only enslaved people who were rebelling had them, but many others used guns to feed or protect their families.
Further, North Carolina enslavers and their legislature created a legal system which permitted Black gun use when it benefited white people or the state, although Nat Turner’s rebellion in neighboring Virginia ultimately made them retreat from the idea. It’s practically impossible to quantify, but anecdotally, there were a great many enslaved people who performed labor with firearms, in addition to those who took up weapons in marronage or rebellion. These were common occurrences.
Why does this story matter for understanding the early American past or the present?
Gun rights and gun violence are such polarizing topics in our present day, and rightfully so. These bits of metal, wood, and plastic can be benign tools for recreation, subsistence, and defense or aggressive and highly destructive instruments of death. I think most people don’t really understand the history of firearm use in this country, and part of that is because there’s so many aspects of it that have been understudied. I think that it’s incumbent on the academy—not just history, but also law, political science, sociology, literature, and other fields—to explore new facets of our nation’s historic relationship to firearms. There are great institutions, like Wesleyan University’s Center for the Study of Guns & Society, that are facilitating some of these discussions but there’s room for so much more scholarship!
If you could invite readers into one scene from your book, what moment would you choose and why?
The book has a fair amount of violence and death, which is an unfortunate reality of writing about firearms, but there are also many moments of pragmatic decision making where enslaved people used firearms to their benefit. One of my favorite episodes took place in 1821, when this planter, Durant Hatch, had maroons hiding out in his neighborhood for about a year who survived by killing and eating white folks’ hogs.
Hatch wrote a letter to a friend and explained that while out hunting, he discovered three armed maroons camped on his land. He ordered them to drop their guns or he would shoot, but they were undaunted. They took cover behind the trees and refused to disarm, creating a very tense moment. One of them declared that he would talk with Hatch if he promised not to try and kill or capture them. The planter agreed, and then tried to convince them to return to enslavement. The only Black man who spoke to Hatch was not remotely interested in surrendering. Hatch left them and returned with friends to capture the maroons, but they fled by the time he returned.
I love this moment because we see, in very practical terms, what firearms could mean for enslaved people who were seizing their liberty. These three could force a standoff, a conversation, and buy themselves time to escape because they were armed. There are a lot more episodes of general, day to day, utilitarian gun use, but some of these dramatic episodes really stand out.
What's one historical source, artifact, or place you'd recommend for readers who want to explore this topic further?
I would have to say coroners’ reports are really interesting! I had made some assumptions about the value of coroner’s reports but Sally Hadden put me onto them. Some of these documents offer revealing eyewitness testimony about incidents of gun violence, whether accidental or otherwise. The reports show how easily some people accessed firearms, which were often not locked away. They also show the extent of some of the injuries people suffered from firearms. People who are interested in 19th century coroners’ reports can probably find them in the county records at their state archive.
Where can readers learn more about your work?
I am still doing research on this subject! I am currently working on an article length project about an enslaved teenager who shoots and kills one of his older brothers in 1840s Wilmington. He appears very briefly in the book but has a much larger story that didn’t really fit. Stay tuned for that! Also… read the book! Order it or just get it from the library. Just give it a read! I occasionally make announcements or share events on Instagram (@akh_at_carolina) but it’s mostly just pictures of food…
Learn more about North Carolina history with these episodes of Ben Franklin’s World. Search Ben Franklin’s World episodes here to see what other states, places, or cities you can do a deep dive on!
Antwain mentions finding coroners' reports at state archives, have you explored your local, county, or state archives? If so, what surprises did you find? If you haven't yet, what documents are you interested in examining?
📝 Hit Reply to share your thoughts. 💬 Join the conversation in our Listener Community.
Links to books in this email are affiliate links through Bookshop.org. Each purchase supports local, independent bookstores and helps sustain Ben Franklin's World at no additional cost to you.
A podcast and newsletter about the people, places, and events that made early America and shape our present-day world
Curious about how early America actually worked, and how it still shapes the
world you live in?
Each week on the Ben Franklin's World podcast, historian Liz Covart, Ph.D., sits down with
the scholars who study early American history to explore the people, places, and
events between 1450 and 1825. Not myths. The evidence, in plain, language.
Winner of the Academy of Podcasters' 2017 Best History Podcast Award and the Daughter of the American Revolution's inaugural Franklin New Media Award, Ben Franklin's World has been downloaded more than 14 million times, and reaches lifelong learners, teachers, family historians, and heritage travelers in more than 100 countries.
The newsletter goes further: It investigates what doesn't fit in our episodes, what to read next, and how the past connects to the present.
Two to three emails a week. No hot takes, no jargon — just history, told well.
Read more from Ben Franklin's World: Early American History
Hello Reader, On November 16, 1776, the Continental Navy Brig Andrew Doria sailed into the harbor of Sint Eustatius, a small Dutch island in the Caribbean, and fired a cannon salute. Overlooking Statia’s harbor, atop a large cliff sat Fort Oranje, the Dutch fort where Sint Eustatius Governor Johannes de Graaff ordered his soldiers to return the Americans’ salute. Statia’s returned salute, known as The First Salute, stands as the first international recognition of the United States as an...
Hello Reader, When we think about the foreign help that won American independence, most of us think of France. But in April 1781, John Adams wrote to a very different set of leaders: the States General of the Dutch Republic. He told them the Dutch and the Americans were so alike that the history of one seemed “but a transcript” of the other. Adams needed Dutch recognition and Dutch loans. But he wasn’t the first American to find help in the Dutch Republic. Dutch merchants had been selling...
Hello Reader, In August 1776, hundreds of British ships surrounded New York Harbor. One observer said it looked as if all of London were afloat. Whether New Yorkers had chosen a side or not, they now lived within range of the largest invasion force any of them had ever seen. But for many New Yorkers, the occupation of their city had already begun. Months earlier, the Continental Army arrived to defend New York. Soldiers barricaded the streets, built fortifications, and stationed themselves...