The Grievance We Skip When We Read the Declaration


Hello, Reader,

On July 4, 1776, the Second Continental Congress adopted the Declaration of Independence. In the weeks that followed, Americans gathered in town squares, churches, coffeehouses, and taverns to hear it read aloud.

We know the phrases they heard: “All men are created equal.” “Life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.”

But the Declaration did not stop there.

It listed a long train of grievances against King George III, and the last of them charged the King with bringing "the merciless Indian Savages" down on the inhabitants of the frontiers.

That grievance was read aloud too. In every town. To every crowd.

Historian Linford Fisher estimates that Europeans and early Americans enslaved more than half a million Indigenous people within the present-day borders of the United States. Most of that enslavement served one purpose: taking Native land.

What does the American Revolution look like when we count that history as part of it?

What this Episode is About

Indigenous enslavement was not a second story running alongside African slavery. It was something different in kind. Europeans and early Americans enslaved people who lived on land they intended to possess, and that made slavery a tool of dispossession. The American Revolution is where the process accelerated.

We're joined by Linford Fisher, a professor of history and the faculty director of the Center for Digital Scholarship at Brown University, and author of Stealing America: The Hidden Story of Indigenous Slavery in U.S. History, and Lorén Spears, an enrolled Narragansett tribal citizen and the executive director of the Tomaquag Museum. Together they built Stolen Relations, a collaborative digital database documenting the lives of enslaved Indigenous people.


In This Episode, You'll Hear:

  • Why stealing people and stealing land were one process rather than two
  • How the Revolution opened what Fisher calls a permissible space for captive raiding on the western frontier
  • How Dawnland nations weighed neutrality, alliance, and survival during the War for Independence

🎧 Listen & Explore

Be sure to listen to and browse the show notes, which include sources, maps, and a full transcript for those who prefer to read or need flexibility.


SUPPORT FOR THIS EPISODE COMES FROM

The Massachusetts Historical Society's new exhibition 1776: Declaring Independence, traces how the Declaration grew from private letters and draft manuscripts into a document that echoed around the world.

On view through December 19,2026


Go Even Deeper

The History Explorers Club is a historian-led membership community for curious adults. It features live conversations with historians, monthly club calls, and a community that finds meaning in the past.


💬 Join the Conversation

Has learning about Indigenous enslavement changed how you view the American Revolution? If so, I'd like to know how.

📨 Email: liz@benfranklinsworld.com

📝 Submit a future episode idea: benfranklinsworld.com/request


Thank you for being a part of this community, and for supporting history that informs, connects, and inspires.

If you'd like to help keep Ben Franklin's World independent and accessible, please consider making a donation.

Happy Exploring,

Liz


❤️ Share this episode: Forward this email to a friend!

📚 New here? Subscribe


📓 Affiliate Disclosure

Links to books in this email are affiliate links through Bookshop.org. Each purchase supports local, independent bookstores and helps sustain Ben Franklin's World at no additional cost to you.

Ben Franklin's World

P.O. Box 180002, Boston , MA 02118
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Ben Franklin's World: Early American History

Curious about how early America actually worked, and how it still shapes the world you live in? Each week on the Ben Franklin's World podcast, historian Liz Covart, Ph.D., sits down with the scholars who study early American history to explore the people, places, and events between 1450 and 1825. Not myths. The evidence, in plain, language. Winner of the Academy of Podcasters' 2017 Best History Podcast Award and the Daughter of the American Revolution's inaugural Franklin New Media Award, Ben Franklin's World has been downloaded more than 14 million times, and reaches lifelong learners, teachers, family historians, and heritage travelers in more than 100 countries. The newsletter goes further: It investigates what doesn't fit in our episodes, what to read next, and how the past connects to the present. Two to three emails a week. No hot takes, no jargon — just history, told well.

Read more from Ben Franklin's World: Early American History

Hello, Reader, In December 1776, a Lenape leader named White Eyes traveled to Philadelphia and stood before the Second Continental Congress. He had not come to declare himself a revolutionary. Nor had he come to pledge loyalty to King George III. He came to test a promise. By then, the Lenape, or Delaware, people had been observing the character of European newcomers for more than 250 years. They had watched a Dutch land agreement they understood as a living relationship become a permanent...

Hello Reader, Today’s featured book opens with a roadside historic marker about the Stono Rebellion, which began on September 9, 1739. While this approaching 287th anniversary doesn't have the same ring as 250, it’s still worth reflecting on this historic moment. Much like the Declaration, the Stono Rebellion was a moment when people sought liberty from an unjust system. But as historian Gautham Rao shows, it was also part of a long, intertwined history of enslavement, law, and policing in...

Cover of Kingdom of Devils

Hello Reader, True crime is a popular topic in media today. You’ve probably seen a Dateline or 48 Hours, two true crime programs with over thirty years on-air, or heard about a popular podcast like Serial. (Ben Franklin’s World listeners might be relieved to know true crime ranked below history podcasts in popularity according to a 2022 survey.) But crime isn’t new, nor is human's fascination with it. Keep reading to learn about a once well-known 1789 murder spree in Kentucky, and how it...